In attempts to find the best red velvet cupcake/cake in Manhattan, Flynn and I have gone to several bakery/cupcake specialty shops within walking distance of our office in the Chelsea Market. We've been to those within the market and those within a few blocks of the market. Upon visiting the famous Billy's and Magnolia I noticed not only that their cupcakes were very similar, but so were their decors. Magnolia was brought to the height of fame for
its appearance in Sex In the City, while Billy's has
magazine clippings and pictures of Katie Holmes pining over theirs. Flynn then proceeded to tell me about this absurd
cupcake war that's been going on in the city for many years. Ridiculous.
Pettiness aside, this is the list of the best and worst red velvet cupcakes we've had.
5.
Ruthy's Bakery - Chelsea Market - 75 Ninth Ave
Although the bakery has a television screen flaunting all of the amazing cake creations they've made over the years [including a Louis Vuitton luggage cake], i've never really had anything in here that's super fresh. their red velvet cupcake was so stale when i had it that i couldn't even finish it. and that says a lot.
also notable: their adjoining cafe has one of the cheapest meals in the chelsea market: falafel for $4 [okay, you can get a slice of pizza for $2, but the falafel is way more filling]. although i think i'm the only one who actually enjoys this falafel, as they stuff soggy eggplant and peppers into it. it sounds gross to most people, but to me it's a yummy cheap lunch [hold the pickles please].
4.
Eleni's - Chelsea Market - 75 Ninth Ave
Although Eleni's red velvet cupcakes are only average, their
peanut butter cupcakes are hands down my favorite cupcake ever. chocolate cake with a half a peanut butter cup baked into it, peanut butter frosting, and topped with the other half of the peanut butter cup. flynn and i went through a period where we got them just about every day.
also notable: the brownie bites are a quick fix to any sweet craving
3.
Billy's Bakery - 184 9th Ave
Walking into Billy's is like walking into the past. the decor, although similar to Magnolias, takes it up a notch and completely encompasses you in the essence of a freshly baked cupcake. Their red velvet cupcake and cake comes with the options of having either a buttercream or creamcheese frosting. I like options.
also notable: their famous icebox cake is light and amazing
2.
Magnolia - 401 Bleecker St
Magnolia has always been a staple cupcake shop for knowing neighborhood locals but, as stated above, their fame was heightened and became much more public after Carrie and Miranda chowed down on their delicious cupcakes in
an episode of Sex In the City. their red velvet also has an amazing buttercream frosting and came in a close second. Apparently there is normally
a line around the block to get into this place, but I guess since i've gone in the middle of a work day i've never experienced it.
also notable: their devils cake with mocha frosting cupcake is absolutely divine
1.
Amy's Bread - Chelsea Market - 75 Ninth Ave
Amy's has THE best red velvet cake we've tried. both the cake and the buttercream frosting is light and fluffy. they also give you HUGE slices, which is always a plus in my book [although it makes my stomach hate me soon after devouring the entire slice]. The best thing about Amy's cakes is that they never have all of their cakes for sale every day. So it's always a happy surprise when you walk by and see the delicious buttercream frosting of the red velvet from the hallway.
also notable: their black and white cake